Skip to main

Best dessert in Menomonee Falls, WI.

Decadent Desserts at Local Deli

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

KIDS TURKEY GOBBLER

Gobble it up! Tender sliced turkey layered on soft bread with melty cheese made just right for little hands and big appetites. A gobbler they’ll actually sit still for!

Add Item

I HAM LEGEND

A legendary stack of savory applewood ham and melty cheese, layered on fresh bread with mayo, lettuce, tomato, and red onion. It’s not just a sandwich it’s a statement.

Add Item

BEEFY TEMPTATION

Stacked on warm sourdough bread, this sandwich brings the flavor with tender roast beef, creamy Muenster cheese, spicy hot giardiniera, mayo, crisp lettuce, juicy tomato, and red onion. It’s bold, messy, and downright irresistible.

Add Item

BLT SANDWICH

Crispy bacon, fresh lettuce, and juicy tomato stacked on toasted bread with creamy mayo simple, satisfying, and always a fan favorite.

Add Item

TURKEY GOBBLER

A stacked classic! Tender sliced turkey piled high with Colby Jack cheese, mayo, crisp lettuce, juicy tomato, and red onion on your choice of bread. It’s the ultimate gobble-worthy bite fresh, flavorful, and filling!

Add Item

BILLY CLUB

Built on toasted sourdough, this stacked favorite features savory applewood ham, tender turkey, melty Colby Jack cheese, creamy mayo, fresh lettuce, tomato, and red onion. A classic combo with a bold twist!

Add Item

BIRDS OF A FEATHER

When chicken and turkey team up, you get double the flavor! Served on toasted sourdough with Colby Jack cheese, mayo, lettuce, tomato, and red onion this sandwich is light, juicy, and totally crave-worthy.

Add Item

KIDS I HAM LEGEND

A legendary stack of savory applewood ham and melty cheese, layered on fresh bread with mayo, lettuce, tomato, and red onion. It’s not just a sandwich it’s a statement.

Add Item

TIRAMISU CAKE

Traditional Italian dessert made of marscarpone cheese and lady fingers soaked in espresso. Lightly dusted with cocoa powder for an elegant touch.

Add Item

CHOCOLATE BROWNIE BITES

Rich, fudgy, and irresistibly chocolatey! These bite-sized brownies are the perfect little indulgence. Soft in the center with a hint of crunch on the edges… Good luck eating just one!

Add Item

CHOCOLATE ICE CREAM

Add Item

RAINBOW CAKE

Bright, bold, and baked to impress! This multi-layered rainbow cake is as fun to look at as it is to eat fluffy, moist, and frosted with sweet, creamy icing. Every slice is a party! ??

Add Item

MUFFINS

Bursting with juicy blueberries and baked to golden perfection! These soft, fluffy muffins are the perfect balance of sweet and tart great for breakfast, a snack, or anytime you need a little pick-me-up.

Add Item

CINNABON® CINNAMON SWIRL CHEESECAKE (CHEESECAKE FACTORY)

CREAMY CHEESECAKE SWIRLED WITH CINNABON®’S ICONIC CINNAMON ROLL FILLING, LAYERED WITH MOIST VANILLA CAKE AND TOPPED WITH A LUSCIOUS CINNAMON CREAM CHEESE FROSTING. IT’S WARM, COMFORTING, AND SWEET JUST LIKE YOUR FAVORITE CINNABON®, BUT IN CHEESECAKE FORM!

Add Item

BLUE MOON

Add Item

BUTTER PECAN

Butter Pecan Flavored Custard with Pecans

Add Item

CAKE POP

? CAKE POPS ? A bite-sized blast of happiness on a stick! Our cake pops are rich, moist cake rolled into perfect balls, dipped in sweet chocolate or vanilla coating, and decked out with fun toppings. Choose from classic chocolate drizzle or pink sprinkle party. These little treats are big on flavor and fun!

Add Item

FRESH STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE (CHEESECAKE FACTORY)

Peanut Butter Chocolate Cheesecake! A chocolate lover’s dream with a peanut butter twist! This rich and creamy cheesecake swirls layers of velvety peanut butter and smooth milk chocolate atop a fudgy brownie crust. Finished with a drizzle of chocolate ganache and a crown of peanut butter mousse, it's the ultimate indulgence for anyone who can’t resist the classic combo. Every forkful delivers bold flavor and melt-in-your-mouth satisfaction.

Add Item

MONSTER COOKIE

Satisfy big cookie cravings with our Devonshire® Premium Monster Cookie. Each bite is full of different textures and tastes from milk chocolate candies and crunchy caramel pieces to butterscotch-flavored chips, pretzels and oats.

Add Item

TRIPLE BERRY TART

Rustic Triple Berry Tarts Handcrafted, each tart is loaded with the perfect balance of blackberries, blueberries, raspberries, and fresh apple slices, all cradled in a flaky, homemade crust. (Additional Cost: Vanilla Ice Cream)

Add Item

SUGAR CONE

Crispy, golden, and delightfully sweet perfect for holding your favorite scoop (or two) of ice cream. A classic treat with a satisfying crunch!

Add Item

SLICE OF CARROT CAKE

Moist, spiced carrot cake layered with rich cream cheese frosting and topped with a hint of sweetness. Classic, comforting, and just the right amount of indulgent one slice won’t be enough! ??

Add Item

APPLE TART

Rustic Apple Tarts. Handcrafted each tart is loaded with the perfect balance of sweet and tangy apples in a soft six-fold pastry crust. Topped with a dash of cinnamon and a light sugar glaze each 4 in. tart has a slightly crunchy bite with a back-of-the-house baked appearance.

Add Item

OREO DREAM EXTREME CHEESECAKE (CHEESECAKE FACTORY)

LAYERS OF OREO® COOKIE CRUST, CREAMY CHEESECAKE LOADED WITH OREO COOKIE PIECES, FUDGE CAKE, AND CHOCOLATE TRUFFLE CREAM. FINISHED WITH A GLOSSY CHOCOLATE GANACHE AND EVEN MORE OREO® CRUMBLE ON TOP. IT’S A RICH, DECADENT, COOKIE-LOVER’S DREAM COME TRUE!

Add Item

Sweet Endings: Indulge in Delicious Desserts

Sweet Endings: Indulge in Delicious Desserts
Indulge in our delectable desserts, from rich chocolate cake to creamy cheesecake. Satisfy your sweet tooth with our homemade pies or try our refreshing fruit sorbets. Our dessert menu offers something for everyone, including gluten-free and vegan options. End your meal on a sweet note with our irresistible desserts.

Convenient Delivery and Pickup Options for Delicious Delights

Convenient Delivery and Pickup Options for Delicious Delights
Indulge in our delectable desserts from the comfort of your home with our convenient delivery and pickup options. Satisfy your sweet tooth with our mouthwatering cakes, pies, and cookies. Whether you're craving a rich chocolate cake or a fruity tart, we've got the perfect treat for you.

Our location